Our Menu

Enjoy Surfside Inn's value menu. All ingredients are locally sourced and of the highest standard.

APPETIZERS

Asian Vegetable Dumplings
served with Asian Dipping Sauce

Lightly Battered Crispy Calamari
served with Tri Color Pepper Rings, Marinara & Garlic Sweet Chili Ginger Dipping Sauce

Mozzarella & Sliced Farm Grown Tomato & Field Greens
seasoned with Olive Oil, Balsamic Glaze & Basil

Prince Edward Island Mussels
sauteed with White Wine & Garlic Butter Sauce
served with Warm Breadsticks

Clams Surfside
Whole Clams lightly topped with Garlic & Breadcrumbs
baked in White Wine & Butter Sauce

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
served with Housemade Cocktail Sauce & Lemon

SOUP & SALAD

Chef's New England Clam Chowder

Mixed Field Greens with Grape Tomatoes, Carrots & Red Onion
served with your choice of Vinaigrette, Mandarin Orange Ginger or Blue Cheese Dressing

Maple Roasted Pecans, Cranberries, Goat Cheese & Field Greens
served with Raspberry Vinaigrette

Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine served with Croutons, White Anchovies & Caesar Dressing

FROM THE FARM

*Prime USDA Buckhead Beef Grilled Rib Eye
served with Potatoes & Seasonal Vegetables 

8 0Z. Prime Filet Mignon
served with Seasoned Red Bliss Potatoes, Seasonal Vegetables & Grilled Peppadews

Mango Chipotle Glazed BBQ Baby Back Ribs
served with Goldeb Fries & Farm Fresh Corn on the Cob

Barbecue Glazed Braised Pork Shank
served with Seasoned Red Bliss Potatoes & Seasonal Vegetables 

Chicken Paillard
Grilled Chicken Breast over Baby Arugula & Chopped Tomatoes topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese

Roasted Long Island Boneless 1/2 Duck
served with Orange Grand Marnier Sauce, Wild Rice & Seasonal Vegetables

FROM OUR FRONTYARD

1 1/2 lb. Steamed Lobster & Grilled Shrimp
served with Seasoned Roasted Red Bliss Potatoes & Farm Fresh Corn on the Cob

Pan Seared Scottish Wild Salmon
served with Seson Roasted Red Bliss Potatoes, Wilted Spinach & Grilled Peppadews

*Sesame Pan Seared Saku Block Ahi Tuna
served with Field Greens drizzled with Balsamic Glaze,
Pickled Ginger & Wasabi

Savanna Style Shrimp
with Andouille Sausage sauteed with Red Peppers,
Green Peppers & Onion over Cheese Grits

PASTA, PASTA, PASTA

Housemade Beef Bolognese
served over Small Rigatoni with Shaved Parmesan Cheese

Sautéed Shrimp & Capellini
tossed with Grape Tomatoes, Basil & Garlic

Housemade Red or White Clam Sauce
served over Fine Linguine with your choice of Housemade Tomato Sauce or Olive Oil, Garlic & Parsley

HOMEMADE COCKTAILS

Toasted Coconut Martini
Coconut Vodka and Coco Lopez served in a Toasted Coconut Rimmed Glass

Watermelon Martini
Fresh Watermelon infused Vodka served with sliced Watermelon

Red Sangria
Select Red Wines mixed with our Secret Ingredients served with sliced Pineapple and Orange

Pineapple Martini
Fresh Pineapple infused Vodka served with sliced Pineapple

Huckleberry Lemonade
Huckleberry Vodka & Homemade Lemonade served with sliced Lemon

Planter's Punch
Rum & Fresh Fruit Juices topped with Meyer's Drunk Rum and served with sliced Orange

Pomegranate Martini
Parma Pomegranate Liqueur & Vanilla Vodka

Surfside's Sunburst
Raspberry Vodka, Chambord & Homemade Lemonade served with sliced Orange

Espresso Martini
Espresso & Vanilla Vodka served with Coffee Beans

Cucumber Martini
Organic Cucumber Vodka served with sliced Cucumber

Skinny Margherita
Skinny Girl Vodka, Agave & Florida Key Lime Juice

SPECIALS


Long Island Scallops with various accompaniments

--- NO SUBSTITUTIONS ---

20% Gratuity may be added to parties of 6 or more

Share plate charge $10

Maximum of 3 credit cards per table

Get in touch

685 Old Montauk Hwy. • P.O. Box 2267 • Montauk, NY 11954
Tel: 631.668.5958 • Fax: 631.668.1200